Friday, July 10, 2009

More on the copyright issue: Read how the lawyer behind Connie Schultz's column explains what happened and what he thinks

The debate over whether changes in copyright law could save newspapers is complex, in part because it seems that Cleveland Plain Dealer columnist Connie Schultz may have mischaracterized the thinking of David Marburger, the lawyer behind the ideas she put forth in her column that prompted a full-scale pie fight over the issue. I'm sorry if this seems too twisted, but I think the best way to explain is to share Marburger's correspondence with me and provide links to his writings that I've uploaded to First, I posted a response from Marburger to my blog post on Schultz's column in which he clarified his views, making them seem, at least to me, different from the way Schultz had presented them. The following were his three main points:

1. We do not advocate a statutory 24-hour moratorium on rewriting news reports originated by others. Like you, we'd vigorously oppose that.
2. We do not think that linking to originators' news sites, as Google News does, is bad; on balance, we think it's good for any news originator.
3. We oppose the "pay wall" concept that many newspaper publishers endorse. For reasons that we summarize in our analyses, we think that it would be futile in the long run.

In response, I asked him: "From what you've written here, I'm not sure she's on the same page as you on a number of points. Am I correct?"

Marburger then sent me back an explanation of what he think happened and why he's concerned about the way bloggers, including me, have characterized his thinking. Before posting that explanation, he asked me to also publish the following:

"I must say that Connie was not calling for a statutory moratorium on rewrites for 24 hrs. Her column was worded as saying that Dan & I specifically recommended that, and my note below explains the origin of her statement. Her column endorsed our 60-page theory, which is pretty analytical. Our analysis calls for restoring common-law unfair competition and unjust enrichment principles by amending the copyright act so that the act clearly doesn't preempt those common-law principles. Neither Connie nor anyone at The Plain Dealer has called for Congress to adopt a prospective statutory moratorium on rewriting factual accounts originated by others."

The following is "the note below" he mentioned in the above statement.

"My brother & I are quite dismayed that so many knowledgeable people think that we advocate a statutory 24-hour moratorium on rewriting original news reports. It is vital to us that correct information be published so that those who are in a position to implement our analyses can assess them for what they really are.
Connie is on the same page with us. The 24-hour thing came from my being too inarticulate in an interview with her. Even though I work with journalists constantly & was one myself, I forget that journalists and lay people equate the "law" with statutes that legislators pass. And since she's married to a legislator she probably equates "law" with statutes quite naturally. Remember that negligence, personal injury, libel, invasion of privacy, fraud, and other commonplace legal rights are common law. No statute involved at all. Unfair competition, too, is common law.
So when Connie asked me what I ideally wd do, I didn't explain the rather dramatic distinction between making a legal argument in a common-law suit to redress a wrong versus imposing a prospective 24-hour moratorium via the overly rigid rules laid down by statutes. I said instead to Connie(paraphrasing): "I'd argue that competitors should have to wait to free-ride until most of the commercial life of a daily news story has elapsed, which is like a day." By that, I failed to explain that I would make that argument in a court case if I were asserting the common-law unfair competition theory to redress a wrong that already had occurred -- which is all that my brother & I seek to restore.
I think that Connie may have interpreted my generalized words to mean that we want to see a statutorily-mandated 24-hour moratorium on rewriting original news reports. As I said, we are dead-set against that because a statutorily-imposed moratorium wd be prospective and inflexible -- not based on real life situations that arise. I don't think that Connie or anyone at the Plain Dealer advocates a statutory 24-hour moratorium per se. What they advocate is legal recourse for direct competitors exploiting commercially the substantial journalistic services of a news originator. We seek to restore that recourse.
By their prospective, inflexible, rigid nature, statutes often empower people way, way more than they should. As we explain in our analyses, the common law is what news originators and society need in circumstances like these; not statutes."

It sure seems to me like there was something lost in the translation between Marburger and Schultz and that his ideas should be judged on their own merits, separate from whatever Schultz has written.

To that end, here's a link to the articles by Marburger and his economist brother, Dan, that provide their thinking in great detail.

I apologize for any confusion I may have created over this issue, but I think ultimately my exchanges with Marburger are leading to more clarity on their thinking on how to help newspapers through these difficult times. I thank him for being so responsive.


  1. John - there's no question that your asking questions helped clarify these issues. That's one of the biggest boons to participating in and adopting an approach that embraces the dialectic that gets going through online interactive information sharing. As a lawyer and as a journalist, I really appreciate the effort you've made here, and the sharing of the information. Now the issue is getting it to everyone else who still thinks the 24 hour moratorium is what was intended.

  2. "embraces the dialectic"
    Nice the Marxists out early this morning.

  3. From David Marburger:

    John: I'm one of the co-authors of the economic and legal analysis that your blog is talking about.

    I think "mischaracterized" is a loaded term -- it suggests blame or fault, which I suspect you don't mean to convey. Given the context of amending the copyright statute, anyone not already immersed in my area of law everyday would use words that connote "statute" or think "statute" when talking briefly about what we conclude and recommend.

    In fact, a young lawyer in our office read my brother's and my analysis a couple of weeks ago. He thought that we wanted Congress to pass a statute that would require free-riders to disgorge ad revenue and give news organizations injunctions, and he asked me what such statutory language might say. He wasn't already conversant with common-law unfair competition or the pre-emption provisions of the copyright act, and so I explained to him that we weren't calling for Congress to pass statutes like that.

    I explained that the common-law already allows those kinds of remedies for unfair competition without any statute, and that they apply to every business except the reporting of daily news. The problem is that the copyright act effectively impedes -- if not actually blocks -- those common-law remedies and common-law unfair competition itself from applying to the business of reporting daily news.

    It is the nuances of the complex interactions between economic principles, the unique and unprecedented qualities of the internet, and both statutory and common law that have converged to bring about the demise of the daily news business.

    If those nuances were so obvious and simple that everyone could describe them fully enough during a coffee break, the problem would have been identified and solved years ago.

    Yet it is those nuances that, in the end, explain in large part what has happened, and what can correct it. Now, let's get to the details; let's get to the merits.

  4. Good information here. I really enjoy reading them every day. I've learned a lot from them.Thanks so much for sharing this information. Greatly help me being a newbie.
    Agen Togel
    Buku Mimpi
    Togel Singapore
    Togel Hongkong
    Togel Sydney
    Bandar Togel
    Livedraw Togel

  5. This is my first time i visit here and I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially it's discussion, thank you.
    hong kong shelf companies

  6. Visit Goa Escorts Agency, the luxurious agency where you can find the most beautiful Call Girls in Goa.

  7. NEW CUM have Fun some With Escorts in Delhi. Short stay UpScAle SErviCe!

  8. Ni Yax Vule Bosew Sonibe Zikijoec Bu Qoj Tuko Nuuq Lawafu Guyapuat

  9. This really an excellent piece of writing. Especially instructive not to mention complete. Thanks a lot for the purpose of having to pay such a lot of time through showing this valuable advice. Nowadays follow-up cash advance All the best. For the purpose of decent piece of writing.

  10. This comment has been removed by the author.

  11. Kudos lots meant for posting a human experience! It’s truly terrific to look at the actual fact that some additionally placed in a trial towards running your web-sites. Currently push Cash Advance I will attempt to certify to check spine legitimate eventually.

  12. Wonderful and amazing blog to read out and to explore such amazing things. Escorts in Arpora

  13. thanks for sharing it. i really like it. always suckses.

    mesin pengolah sampah

  14. thanks for sharing it. i really like it. always suckses.

    kertas nasi

  15. thanks for sharing it. i really like it. always suckses.

    tempat sampah

  16. Excellent article. Keep writing such kind of info on your
    page. Im really impressed by your site.

    Agen Domino99

    Agen Poker

    Domino99 Online

    Poker Online

    Poker Online Indonesia

  17. great information sharing with us, I like your explanation which you have discusses in your post, If any one needed hosting services for wordpress website visit $1 web Hosting, form there you can get hosting with free domain name services in just one dollar.

  18. Rajasthan University BA  1st Year Result 2018

    Shekhawati University BA Result 2018

    Matsya University BA Result 2018

    Brij University BA Result 2018

    Agra University BA Admit Card 2018

  19. Get Periods Immediately How to Get Periods Immediately In One Day Natural Home Remedies 2018

  20. Bandar Judi Online love to read your article. I hope can still continue reading your next article. hopefully your website growing. Thank you!

  21. PREDIKSI ANGKA TOGEL think your website is pretty good. Many articles are very useful for everyone. I am sure your website will grow in the future. Good Luck


    Promo Kapal4d:
    *Hadiah Bolak-Balik 2D,3D,4D
    *Bonus New Member Rp. 10.000,-
    *Bonus Setiap Deposit 1% (tanpa batas)
    *Bonus Refferal 1%

    Dengan Diskon & Hadiah Untuk Semua Pasaran:
    *4D : 66% x3000
    *3D : 59% x400
    *2D : 29% x70
    *2DD : 27% x65
    *2DT : 25% x70
    DAFTAR :
    LINE : kapal4d
    WA : +855962200895
    SALAM JP ..

    bandar togel
    Agen togel
    togel online
    togel online terpercaya
    buku mimpi togel
    bandar togel terpercaya
    main togel
    prediksi jitu

  23. Kapal4D is bandar togel online in Indonesia providing game of numbers shoot for the most popular market in indonesia. Kapal4d Registration provides the best service with customer service who has experience and ready to serve its member main ( main togel ) 24-hour non-stop togel Ease of Transaction supported by 4 Bank of Indonesia (BCA, BNI, BRI Mandiri). KAPAL4D (bandar togel teraman ) ( bandar togel ) By having a user here who play ( togel online ) can gamble togel ( Agen togel )for the Singapore market ( togel singapore ), Sidney ( togel sydney ), Hongkong ( togel hongkong ). Play Togel Online ( Agen togel )Live in Smartphone or wap version where and anytime.

  24. Your information is good and friendly this article very helpful for me.Thanks
    Menang Ceme
    Bandar Ceme
    Ceme Online
    Ceme 99
    Qiu Ceme

  25. Your information is good and friendly this article very helpful for me.Thanks
    Menang Ceme
    Bandar Ceme
    Ceme Online
    Ceme 99
    Qiu Ceme

  26. I am happy with your article, Fajartoto think your website is pretty good. Many articles are very useful for everyone. I am sure your website will grow in the future. Fajartoto will always support your website, hopefully more advanced. keep the spirit... thanks

    Agen Togel Terpercaya
    Situs Togel Online
    Togel Online Terpercaya
    Togel Online
    Bandar Togel Online Terpercaya
    Bandar Togel Hk
    Situs Casino Online
    Prediksi Hongkong
    Syair Togel Hk

  27. The choices of where and how to file an entity are often prompted by entertainment lawyers but then driven by situation-specific variables, including tax concerns relating to the film or motion picture company sometimes.

  28. Yuk Buruan ikutan bermain di website
    Sekarang spokerqq Memiliki Game terbaru Dan Ternama loh...
    => Bonus Refferal 15%
    => Bonus Turn Over 0,5%
    => Minimal Depo 20.000
    => Minimal WD 20.000
    => 100% Member Asli
    => Pelayanan DP & WD 24 jam
    => Livechat Kami 24 Jam Online
    => Bisa Dimainkan Di Hp Android
    => Di Layani Dengan 6 Bank Terbaik
    => 1 User ID 8 Permainan Menarik
    Ayo gabung sekarang juga hanya dengan
    mengklick POKER ONLINE
    WHATSAPP : +855967136164
    PIN BB : 2B13CFDA
    PIN BB : E34BB179
    LINE ID : sweetycandys
    Blogger :

  29. WE ARE THE BEST ESCORTS SERVICE PROVIDER IN VARIOUS LOCATION COME AND FEEL HEREOUR SPLENDID SERVICE THAT YOU WILL NEVER FORGET.Call Girls in AerocityEscort Service in AerocityRussian Escorts in AerocityCall Girls in JaipurEscorts Service in JaipurRussian Escorts in JaipurEscorts Service in AgraCall Girls in AgraRussian Escorts in AgraCall Girls in DelhiRussian Escorts in MahipalpurRussian Escorts in MahipalpurIndependent Housewife Escorts in DelhiRussian Escorts in FaridabadBook call girls service in FaridabadRussian Escorts in Surajkund

  30. Once they understand the demands of their clients then they act in accordance with that. Once you get along with these women then you are guaranteed to have an amazing time with them.

    Mumbai Escorts
    Russian Escorts in Mumbai
    Goa Escorts
    Russian Escorts in Goa
    Call Girls in Goa
    Goa Escorts

  31. They understand clients’ demands and requirements properly.

    Call Girls in Goa