Saturday, May 2, 2009

Former Editor Tim McGuire should follow his own advice to media critics

Tim McGuire should consider following his own advice to media critics. Point No. 2 in his post on media criticism is good advice for any opinion writer: “Keep the focus of your criticism narrow and manageable. Words like “always” and “never” cheapen most arguments. Those words tend to make you seem silly and painfully uninformed. Allow wiggle room.”

So what does he do in his own piece? He does exactly what he complains bugs him about today’s media critics. He says, “I have found it mighty maddening lately that everybody who talks about newspapers, media and the future of said media is so damned certain about just about everything.”

Really, Tim? “Everybody?” Come on. Taking this approach makes him sound like a thin-skinned journalist flinching at the beating the profession he loves is taking from many in the new rough and tumble environment of the Internet. I can understand why he might think that of Michael Wolff or Jeff Jarvis. But how about David Carr or Howard Kurtz, Jack Shafer or Alan Mutter?

I, too, am one who promotes the value of civil conversation. I started a web site for the E.W. Scripps Co., RedBlueAmerica.com, dedicated to that idea in the areas of culture, politics and religion. (By the way, it failed.) And I think McGuire makes some excellent suggestions. But frankly, in the end, I don’t think journalists come off well telling others how to criticize us. There have to be times when a blunt instrument is applied. Sometimes we deserve just that. Take the Los Angeles Times and the Staples arena section. Or the Chicago Tribune and its test-marketing of stories. Or in the case of my former paper, the Rocky Mountain News, when we got lashed from twittering from the funeral of a child. If editors don’t like it, they can fight back. They should. And I did.

Don't get me wrong. I agree in general with McGuire’s remarks applied to critical writing. But doesn’t it strike anybody else as odd that a journalist whose work is protected by the First Amendment is arguing that it would be better if people didn’t use all the space afforded them under the same guarantee of freedoms?

McGuire’s conclusion seems more directed at making the lives of the subjects of criticism easier and more pleasant – who cares? – than in encouraging a robust and incisive dialogue.

“I simply offer the possibility that civil criticism and constructive ideas will make improving the media a more pleasant and a more satisfying intellectual undertaking,” he writes.

For whom? It seems to me that the critics are having a ball. It’s the journalists who aren’t enjoying themselves. How many people, other than them, care?

78 comments:

  1. John,

    Well said.

    Let's also examine what is being criticized. In my case, it's not newspapers but newspapers' strategies - not doing enough to transform themselves for the realities of this new age.

    I criticize myself, both because I was a newspaper online exec and didn't do enough and because I now see that I didn't raise enough alarms. I get criticized for raising alarms too loudly. But I should be criticized for the opposite: not being loud enough.

    Should I and others I agree with be criticized for "being so damned certain"? Well, perhaps. But I'd say that the internet and its impact on newspapers was a certainty and the results of not acting also proved to be a certainty. I'm certain that paper is a model that will not grow or come back.

    What I'm not certain about, of course, is what comes in its place. No one can be certain about that. But I am doing what I can to find certainty, running a project in new business models for news at CUNY's Graduate School of Journalism, where I teach, and working with startups and news companies. Certainty will come only from experimentation and success and failure.

    You're most right in your primary point: It won't come from complaining about critics.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks, Jeff.

    I think what's problematic is treating the newspaper industry as monolithic. There's no question that the industry for the most part has been slow in its response to the possibilities of new media. But I was encouraged just yesterday by a guest post on newsosaur about a hyperlocal site in Maine. What they're doing is suggestive of a new model, and it includes print. But it's not what anybody associated with a metropolitan or even mid-size newspaper operation is used to and it may not be what they hope journalism would be. To me, though, it's exciting.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have read the article which says about the one nature to mold the situation and about the media critics.I agree with the point that what's problematic is treating the newspaper industry as monolithic.They are giving information at anonymous cost without fully proof.I want to highlight some facts with former editor and their critics level position.

    nahrungsergänzung

    ReplyDelete
  4. There are numerous incredible online suppliers of private understudy advances. These banks offer easy to use sites that permit you finish the whole application process online from the solace of your home. www.usacheckcashingstore.com/san-diego

    ReplyDelete
  5. They're likewise not the most straightforward to get affirmed for either. With every one of the banks as yet feeling the impacts of the retreat, belts have been fixed the nation over concerning bank administrations including advances - this implies unless you have a squeaky clean financial record, you may think that its hard to get an advance from a bank once they play out a credit keep an eye on you. Payday Loans

    ReplyDelete
  6. Super website with a great sharing and amazing stories is ur web.. please keep doing what u do now.. thanks to you.
    Agen Bandarq

    Agen domino

    Domino Online

    agen Bandarq

    Bandar domino99
    agen domino online

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thank you for another essential article. I have learned a lot from your article. Thank so much, again!
    zoosk login flip diving amazon underground apk

    ReplyDelete

  8. The share your really gives us excitement. Thanks for your sharing. If you feel tired at work or study try to participate in our games to bring the most exciting feeling. Thank you!
    hotmail sign in | red ball | 192.168.1.1

    ReplyDelete
  9. I like your opinion. your opinion is really too good. i like this page and post. thanks for share such a great opinion.
    bandar togel online

    ReplyDelete
  10. You've got made an awesome podium getting a number of most up-to-date reports with regards to leisure. Currently let me comply with your web site to get current. Currently follow-up each of our search phrase Cash Advance Cheers pertaining to wonderful article talk about.

    ReplyDelete
  11. very nice and well done dear nice work keep it up
    SpyHunter Serial Key

    ReplyDelete
  12. Excellent submit! Thank you regarding useful submit. I know this kind of submit provides aided myself help save much time regarding exploring some other related content in order to locate just what My partner and I needed. Today just click here check cashing Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  13. YOU CAN DOWNLOAD HERE....
    Cinema 4D R19 Crack
    Cinema 4D R19 Crack is the latest and comprehensive powerful tool which is used by image and graphic designers and artists. Visualization and broadcasting features make the best software.
    http://productkeypro.com/cinema-4d-r19-crack/

    YOU CAN LEARN HERE MORE AND MORE....
    bandicam 4.0.0 crack
    Bandicam 4.0.0 Crack is very famous, helpful, comprehensive and compatible software that record every moment on your desktop screen......
    http://productkeypro.com/bandicam-4-0-0-crack/

    ReplyDelete
  14. Selamat datang di PunyaPoker.net
    Mari Bergabung Bersama Kami, Tersedia 7 Permainan Dalam 1 User ID:
    - Sakong (New Game).
    - Bandar Poker (New Game).
    - BandarQ (Hot Game).
    - Poker.
    - Domino.
    - Capsa Online.
    - AduQ.

    Apa Saja Kelebihan Bermain Di Wesbsite PunyaPoker.net? Berikut Ini Kelebihannya :
    - BONUS TURNOVER 0.5% SETIAP HARI SENIN Dan Tanpa Batas.
    - BONUS REFERAL 10% +10% SEUMUR HIDUP!! Ingat Seumur HIDUP.
    - MIN DEPO IDR 10.000 Dan Prosesnya Super Cepat 1 Menit Selesai.
    - Permainan Bisa Dimainkan Di Smartphone Versi Android Dan Iphone.
    - Win rate 98%.
    - No robot.
    - Fair play 100% player vs player.
    Jadi Jangan Tunggu Lagi? Ayo Segera Bergabung Sebelum Ketinggalan Promonya :)
    Domino QQ
    Texas Poker Indonesia
    Agen Sakong Online
    Agen Capsa Susun
    Agen AduQ
    Agen BandarQ
    Agen Bandar Poker

    ReplyDelete
  15. I knew that we should follow the former editing features by getting help from here. Windows 7 ultimate

    ReplyDelete
  16. i visit this post. i am feeling happy to see this post because this post is very helpful for me, keep it up! sir
    Microsoft office Crack

    ReplyDelete
  17. TEMPLE TALK is one of the best site for talking about journalism and Media.ProgDVB Pro Crack

    ReplyDelete
  18. Excellent Temple talk for every in the media journalism. I follow Temple Talk's Features carefully. good job. keep it up
    EaseUs Data Recovery

    ReplyDelete
  19. you are sharing useful article. Thanks for sharing data that helping to every one
    Freemake Video Converter Key

    ReplyDelete
  20. UNTUK PECINTA TOGEL MANIA. MARI GABUNG YUK SEKARANG JUGA DI KAPAL4D (BANDAR TOGEL ONLINE MENJAMIN KENYAMANAN PEMAIN DALAM BERMAIN)

    Kami Memiliki Promo:
    *Hadiah Bolak-Balik 2D,3D,4D (min pembelian pada line bb 15rb)
    *Bonus New Member Rp. 10.000,-
    *Bonus Setiap Deposit 1% (tanpa batas)
    *Bonus Refferal 1%

    Dengan Diskon & Hadiah Untuk Semua Pasaran:
    *4D : 66% x3000
    *3D : 59% x400
    *2D : 29% x70
    *2DD : 27% x65
    *2DT : 25% x70

    LINE : kapal4d
    WA : +855962200895
    BBM : D8C9D042/D8E09743
    daftar : www.kapalair.com/ref/taurus

    bandar togel
    Agen togel
    togel online
    togel online terpercaya
    buku mimpi togel
    bandar togel terpercaya
    main togel
    link alternative kapal4d

    ReplyDelete
  21. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  22. very useful post for me.Thanks a lot.plz keep it up.
    Reiboot Pro Crack

    ReplyDelete
  23. Very useful and inspiring post. Thankyou very much.
    TuneUp Utilities 2018 crack

    ReplyDelete
  24. This is amazing. i appreciate the effort of this man. (y)
    Total AV Antivirus Serial Key

    ReplyDelete
  25. Awesome
    Latest Dictionary Software Link
    http://crackedsoftz.com/latest-oxford-dictionary-software-2018-free-download/

    ReplyDelete
  26. Kapal4D is bandar togel online in Indonesia providing game of numbers shoot for the most popular market in indonesia. Kapal4d Registration provides the best service with customer service who has experience and ready to serve its member main ( main togel ) 24-hour non-stop togel Ease of Transaction supported by 4 Bank of Indonesia (BCA, BNI, BRI Mandiri). KAPAL4D (bandar togel teraman ) ( bandar togel ) By having a user here who play ( togel online ) can gamble togel ( Agen togel )for the Singapore market ( togel singapore ), Sidney ( togel sydney ), Hongkong ( togel hongkong ). Play Togel Online ( Agen togel )Live in Smartphone or wap version where and anytime.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Bandar Togel Terpercaya
    Kapal4D.com Adalah bandar togel online di Indonesia menyediakan permainan tembak angka untuk pasaran yang paling diminati di indonesia. Pendaftaran Kapal4d memberikan Pelayanan terbaik dengan customer servis yang sudah berpegalaman dan siap melayani membernya untuk main togel ) 24 jam non-stop Kemudahan Bertransaksi didukung oleh 4 Bank INDONESIA (BCA,BNI, BRI Mandiri). KAPAL4D (bandar judi togel teraman ),(bandar togel teraman ) ,Dengan memiliki user disini yang main togel secara online bisa judi togel untuk pasaran ( togel singapore ),( togel sydney ),( togel hongkong ).( Agen togel ) Langsung di Smartphone maupun versi wap dimana dan kapan saja, Berserta Bonus Promo yang menarik dan referal seumur hidup.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Thanks for sharing your info. I really appreciate your efforts and I will be waiting for your further write.
    Thanks for sharing!
    www.myindianfestivals.in/

    ReplyDelete
  29. Great info. I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have.Click Here...

    ReplyDelete
  30. johntemple is very lovely site, great information, lovely thought, i would like to visit again and again.
    ROMANTIC SHAYARI

    Love Shayari

    Anniversary Shayari

    ReplyDelete